Skip to content
DekkoSecure
All articles

Industry Insights · Law firms · 8 min read

Secure File Sharing for Law Firms and Attorneys: What the Rules Expect

Secure file sharing for law firms: what ABA Rule 1.6(c), Opinions 477R and 483, and ASCR rule 9 expect, how common methods compare, and practical controls.

Law firms send and receive files that clients expect to stay private: draft pleadings, discovery productions, medical records, deal documents and privileged advice. Clients, co-counsel, experts and the other side all need copies, and every handoff is a chance for the wrong person to see something.

This guide explains how the duty of confidentiality applies to file sharing in the United States and Australia, compares common ways firms share files and lists practical controls. It is general information, not legal advice: firms should check their own jurisdiction's rules.

What does secure file sharing mean for a law firm?

For a law firm, secure file sharing means exchanging client files with reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized access: access limited to the people on each matter, the ability to withdraw it and a record of who opened what. ABA Model Rule 1.6(c) states the US model; in Australia, the confidentiality duty is rule 9 of the Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules.

The duty of confidentiality in the United States

Model Rule 1.6(c): reasonable efforts

The ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct serve as models for the ethics rules of most US jurisdictions, so each state's wording can differ. Rule 1.6(c) requires a lawyer to make "reasonable efforts" to prevent information relating to a client's representation from being disclosed inadvertently or without authorization, and to prevent unauthorized access to it.

Comment 18 lists factors for judging whether those efforts are reasonable: the sensitivity of the information, the likelihood of disclosure without extra safeguards, the cost and difficulty of those safeguards, and how much they would get in the way of representing clients. An unauthorized disclosure doesn't violate paragraph (c) if the lawyer made reasonable efforts to prevent it. Comment 19 adds that a lawyer transmitting client information must take reasonable precautions to keep it from unintended recipients.

Rule 1.1, Comment 8: technology competence

Under Comment 8 to Rule 1.1, staying competent includes keeping abreast of the benefits and risks of relevant technology. How a firm shares files is one of those technology choices.

ABA Formal Opinion 477R (2017)

Formal Opinion 477R, "Securing Communication of Protected Client Information", was issued in May 2017 and revised later that month. The ABA's summary says a lawyer generally may send client information over the internet after making reasonable efforts to prevent inadvertent or unauthorized access. Special precautions may be required when a client agreement or the law calls for them, or when the information needs a higher degree of security.

The opinion treats unencrypted email as generally acceptable for routine client communication, not for everything. As the ABA Journal reported, it gives seven considerations:

  1. the nature of the threat
  2. how client information is transmitted and where it is stored
  3. the use of reasonable electronic security measures
  4. how electronic communications about clients should be protected
  5. labeling client information as privileged and confidential
  6. training lawyers and nonlawyer assistants in technology and cybersecurity
  7. due diligence on vendors that provide technology services

ABA Formal Opinion 483 (2018)

Formal Opinion 483, "Lawyers' Obligations After an Electronic Data Breach or Cyberattack", was issued on October 17, 2018. As summarized in the ABA's Law Practice Today, it discusses the duty to monitor for a breach, stop it and restore systems, determine what happened, and tell current clients about a material loss or compromise of their information. A record of who opened each file helps with the third step.

Australia: rule 9 of the Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules

The Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules (ASCR), developed by the Law Council of Australia, apply through legislation in every state and territory, with some local variations. Rule 9 says a solicitor must not disclose information that is confidential to a client and acquired during the engagement to anyone outside the law practice and the people it engages for the client's legal services (rule 9.1). Exceptions include the client authorizing disclosure and the solicitor being permitted or compelled by law to disclose.

Rule 9 doesn't prescribe technology. It sets the outcome, and a file sent to the wrong address or left on an open link puts that outcome at risk. Larger firms may also be covered by the Privacy Act 1988 and its Notifiable Data Breaches scheme.

How common ways of sharing files measure up

The table compares common methods against what these duties ask for: limiting who can open a file, being able to take access back and knowing who opened it. Details vary by product and settings.

Who can open the fileCan access be withdrawn?Record of who opened itMain weakness
Email attachmentAnyone who receives it, including by forwarding or a mistyped addressNoNoNo control after sending; 477R accepts it for routine communication, not for all information
Password-protected attachmentAnyone with the file and the passwordNoNoWorks only if the password travels by a separate channel
Consumer cloud storage linkAnyone with the link, depending on settingsUsually, by disabling the linkVariesLinks get forwarded; the platform may hold the encryption keys
SFTP serverAccounts the firm sets upYes, by removing the accountServer logs, if keptClients need software and accounts; see SFTP vs FTPS
Matter-based workspace or client portalNamed people on each matterYesUsuallyDepends on permissions, encryption and who at the provider can open files
USB drive or discAnyone holding itNoNoLoss or theft, unless the media is encrypted

Practical controls for law firm file sharing

  • Matter-based workspaces. Keep each matter's files in one place, shared with that matter's team and outside parties, not scattered across inboxes.
  • Permission levels. Give each person the least access they need: view only for a review copy, upload for a client sending documents, editing for co-counsel.
  • Expiry. Put an end date on shares with experts, vendors and other outside parties.
  • Revocation. Withdraw access as soon as a file reaches the wrong person or a party leaves the matter.
  • Audit. Keep a record of who viewed, downloaded or changed each file, for supervision and for breach response under Opinion 483.
  • Signing. Collect signatures on engagement letters and consents where the file lives, so the record stays with it. See digital vs electronic signatures.
  • Labels, training and vendor checks. Opinion 477R's last three considerations: mark confidential files, train staff and check how a provider handles client data.

Where DekkoCORE fits

In DekkoCORE, a firm can set up a Hub for each matter and invite clients, co-counsel and experts as External Members. External Members see only the folders shared with them and can't see other external parties. Each share uses one of seven permission levels, from Listing only to Full permissions, and can have an expiry date and be revoked instantly. View only shares open in a secure viewer and can have downloads off.

Files are encrypted on the user's device before upload and decrypted on the recipient's device, so DekkoCORE stores only ciphertext and never has the keys; not even DekkoSecure can read them. Read more about end-to-end encryption. eSignature requests track several signatories until the last one signs, and every view, download, signature, approval and version is logged in an audit log that exports as CSV. These features support the controls above; whether they meet a firm's obligations depends on its own jurisdiction's rules. See our guide to secure file sharing and DekkoCORE for professional services.

Common questions

Frequently Asked Questions

What is ABA Formal Opinion 477R?

ABA Formal Opinion 477R, "Securing Communication of Protected Client Information", is a 2017 ABA ethics opinion. It says a lawyer generally may send client information over the internet after making reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized access, and may need special precautions for highly sensitive information or when a client agreement or the law requires them.

Can lawyers email client documents without encryption?

Opinion 477R treats unencrypted email as generally acceptable for routine client communication, but not in every case. Highly sensitive information, a client's instructions or the law can call for stronger measures, and state rules and ethics opinions differ, so firms should check their own jurisdiction.

What does ABA Model Rule 1.6(c) require?

Rule 1.6(c) requires a lawyer to make reasonable efforts to prevent client information from being disclosed inadvertently or without authorization, and to prevent unauthorized access to it. Comment 18 lists factors for judging reasonableness, including the sensitivity of the information, the likelihood of disclosure and the cost of safeguards.

What does ABA Formal Opinion 483 say about data breaches?

Formal Opinion 483, issued in October 2018, covers lawyers' obligations after a data breach or cyberattack. It discusses monitoring for breaches, stopping them and restoring systems, finding out what happened and telling current clients when their information has been materially compromised.

What is rule 9 of the Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules?

Rule 9 says a solicitor must not disclose a client's confidential information to anyone outside the law practice and the people it engages for the client's matter, except in listed cases such as client authorization or legal compulsion. The rules apply through state and territory legislation, with some local variations.

What should a law firm look for in a file sharing service?

Look for encryption, matter-based access with permission levels, expiry and revocation, an audit log, two-factor authentication for outside parties and clear answers on who at the provider can open files. These map to Opinion 477R's considerations on security measures and vendor due diligence.

Like to learn more?

Talk to our team about protecting your most sensitive files and evidence.